Best Mirrorless Camera:
Shootout of Six Top Models

Dick De Jong, Updated August 15, 2012

Panasonic GX1


With the proliferation of mirrorless camera models, this compact system camera category is becoming overcrowded with products with overlapping features.

Take Panasonic for example, its G lineup of mirrorless cameras includes multiple series, G, GF, GH, and now GX - it's easy to become befuddled.

Within this range of models, you can see the Panasonic designers and engineers attempt to delineate different products that will appeal to all types of photographers, from those graduating from simpler point and shoot cameras or smartphones to the old-timers that are looking for DSLR quality and features in a lighter form factor.

For the latter group, the Panasonic G3 or the video friendly GH2 scratch that itch. For the former group who have been weaned on cameras that you hold at arm's length to shoot because they don't have viewfinders, the GX1 with a touch sensitive screen fills the bill.

Best Mirrorless Cameras 2012 Panasonic GX1

What's Hot about the Panasonic GX1

  • 16MP CMOS Four Thirds sensor
  • Good image quality and wide dynamic range up to ISO 12800
  • Touch sensitive LCD including touch auto focus
  • Compatible with a large selection of Micro Four Thirds lenses
  • RAW capture format
  • Built-in pop-up flash and hot shoe
  • 1080p video at 30 fps and 720p at 60 fps
  • Integrated stereo microphones
  • Adjustable mic level while recording
  • Up to 4 fps burst mode when shooting RAWs

What's Not So Caliente about the Panasonic GX1

  • Optical Image stabilization works only when OIS lenses are attached
  • Fixed, non-articulating screen
  • Contrast detect auto focus can be slow especially in low light
  • Hand grip is inadequate when larger lenses are attached
  • When in Burst mode above 3 fps, Live View and auto focus not available
  • No external microphone inputs
  • LVF2 Electronic viewfinder accessory costs an extra $225

Design

With the compact 14-42mm kit lens attached, the Panasonic GX1 feels comfortable and solid with a hand wrapped around the grip. With a lens this size or even better, with the stubby 14mm prime lens, the camera delivers on the dream of a high quality interchangeable lens model that fits into your pocket (albeit cargo pants size).

Of course, if you are planning on mounting a longer telephoto lens, portable turns into totable - as you would expect.

More importantly, as the lenses becomes longer and heavier, the adequacy of the hand grip and balance of the camera quickly diminishes.

Best Mirrorless Cameras 2012 Panasonic GX1
Panasonic GX1 with an assortment of compatible Micro Four Thirds lenses

As a graphic example, we attached the Olympus 75-300mm Micro Four Thirds lens on the GX1 and the three fingers that fit on the grip were simply not enough to hold the camera with any sense of confidence or balance.

Holding the camera required both hands, which again is not surprising. But now if you plan to operate the camera with the touchscreen, you may need to sprout a third hand or carry a tripod.

With that said, any mirrorless camera body the size of the GX1 would have similar problems balancing a long telephoto lens. And to reiterate, this solidly built Panasonic feels quite comfy with more compatibly sized lenses.

Considering its small body, the GX1 provides a lot of manual dials and buttons to change most of the important settings without having to open the on-screen menu. A fact those migrating from DSLRs will appreciate.

Best Mirrorless Cameras 2012 Panasonic GX1
Top and Back Views of the Panasonic GX1 without a lens

On the top is the Mode dial with the traditional P, A, S, M settings along with Scene, Art and two Custom modes, which you can create in the menu.

Also of note, the red button next to the shutter release is a dedicated Movie button. Click on it and the camera starts shooting video.

The integrated pop-up flash may not be the most powerful, but the GX1 also supplies a hot shoe for an external flash unit. Though if you use the optional electronic viewfinder, it will occupy the hot shoe.

For Panasonic GX1 memory cards, see Camera Accessories

On the back is the fixed three inch LCD screen surrounded by various function buttons. I especially like the dedicated ISO button that jumps right to that spot on the menu.

If you are from the smartphone generation, the GX1 had you at "touchscreen." You can not only navigate through the menu by touch, you can also set it to auto focus on a spot that you touch or even release the shutter.

The screen is responsive. Though those with big paws may wish for bigger buttons to tap. And if you are not the touchy type, you can turn off the touchscreen feature.

Image Quality

Best Mirrorless Cameras 2012 Panasonic GX1

Objectively, the image quality from 16MP sensor coupled with the Venus processor is very good and made even better with a high end lens. It's a definite step up from the 12MP sensor found in earlier Panasonic compact system cameras.

This photo of the Anish Kapoor sculpture at the Met, was shot with a 14mm lens, f/3.5, 1/125 sec, 1600 ISO. At that ISO setting, the RAW image exhibited noticeable noise, but a bit of post processing of the file in Camera Raw and the noise was easily managed.

Of course, when you push the ISO above 3200, you will need to be more aggressive with your post processing or less critical about the noise.

With that positive affirmation of the GX1's image quality, I must admit that subjectively, I was usually underwhelmed with the results coming straight out of the camera. In technical terms, the images had no oomph. The shots had none of the wow factor that the Pentax K-01 produced.

Granted, if you want more oomph and you are shooting JPEGs, you can go into the Photo Style option and choose Vivid. Or if you pick Custom, you can tweak Contrast, Sharpness, Saturation and Noise Reduction.

And most photographers who shoot RAW expect the initial image to be fairly flat, which gives them a neutral canvas to perform their post processing magic. Let's just say that the RAW files from the GX1 are without a doubt flat and neutral.

The video quality is also very good. This montage is from the Kite Festival in Austin. The continuous auto focus worked well, as you would expect on a bright sunny day. And as you blindly hope it will since it was impossible to see anything in the LCD because of the glare of the sun.

The sound was captured through the integrated stereo microphones, which is not ideal, but the GX1 does not provide inputs for external mikes. Best Mirrorless Cameras 2012 Panasonic GX1

Features

The top line feature on the Panasonic GX1 is the touchscreen and with its responsiveness, it deserves that spot.

I wish the screen articulated. It is very hard to view in bright light and the optional viewfinder, which is excellent, costs an extra $225.

If your photos of the Empire State Building make it look like the leaning tower of Pisa, you'll appreciate that Panasonic has built in a Level Gauge that you can display on your viewfinder.

The GX1 offers a burst shooting rate up to 20 fps, but the quality of the shots is sketchy. You can shoot higher quality RAW files up to 4 fps, which is not bad.

The downside is at that speed, Live View and auto focus do not function. Basically, you cannot see what you are shooting. You need to reduce the burst mode to 3 fps to see the images in Live View. Best Mirrorless Cameras 2012 Panasonic GX1

Like any respectable mirrorless camera nowadays, if you turn the Mode dial to SCN, the GX1 offers a long list of Scene presets including Portrait, Soft Skin, Pet, Party, and Baby 1 and 2.

If you are capturing JPEGs, you can turn to the Palette icon on the Mode dial and choose from Creative Control options like Expressive, Retro, High Key and High Dynamic.

The GX1 only supplies image stabilization when an OIS lens is attached..

The GX1 does not offer a built-in GPS.

Verdict

If you are looking for a well performing, small mirrorless camera with a responsive touchscreen, then the Panasonic GX1 should be considered.

The image quality from its 16MP Four Thirds sensor is very good and the camera is reasonably priced. And the range of compatible Micro Four Thirds lenses is extensive.

Then again, I still prefer the similarly sized Sony NEX-5N, which sports a bigger APS-C sensor and an articulating touchscreen.

Panasonic GX1 Photo Gallery


More about the Panasonic GX1

Panasonic GX1 spec sheet

Reader Comments(11 comments)

Posted Feb 24, 2013 4:41:24 PM
By ARTHUR MCVAY
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
I OWN A V1, I HAVE HEARD ALL THE NEGATIVE COMMENTS AND WHILST THEY MAY ALL BE VALID, I CANNOT FAULT THE QUALITY OF THE PICTURES I HAVE TAKEN WITH IT
Posted Jan 18, 2013 6:58:23 AM
By stephen rudolph
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
leaving out the x-pro1 and omd-em5 is like leaving out Angelina Jolie or Charlize Theron out of the 'list of the top 10 sexiest hollywood actresses '. Top 6 according to who's ranking ? and if its in sales, it doesnt make it a 'top' camera. a lot of people buy according to price and not quality.
Posted Dec 28, 2012 10:45:52 AM
By Francis Josey
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
I think you did a fine job with the article and agree with your conclusions, I DO wish you had included the NEX 7 and the X-pro 1. I own 4 MILCs, Sony 5n and 7, Fuji X-pro 1, and the Samsung NX-200. All great performers, but the 5n is amazing for engineering reasons I will never understand. It beats all the others although they all have strong points. I'll end with a question, Did you consider including the Ricoh GXR A16 at all ????
Posted Nov 14, 2012 8:12:41 AM
By Bill F.
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
Why didn't you include the Fujifilm X-pro 1 or the XE-1? These have excellent image quality, easily rivaling top-end DSLRs. Excellent lenses and easy to use. The ONLY mirrorless cameras to date that do not have a low-pass filter, and so give very sharp images. Just wondering why these were avoided (or just overlooked?)
Posted Nov 12, 2012 4:03:10 PM
By Docrwm
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
The K-01 has dropped in price, with the 40XS pancake lens, to $349 at many sellers. The Q has dropped to as low as $299 with 01 Prime lens and frequently goes for $346 with it or the 02 Zoom. At those prices they are killer cameras and real bargains.
Posted Nov 12, 2012 4:00:54 PM
By Docrwm
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
Well, the Q is now selling for around $350 for camera plus either the 01 Prime or the 02 Zoom Standard Lens. I got my Q with the 01 8.5mm f1.9 lens for $299 BNIB last week. So, at that price (and with an adapter for my K mount lenses) it's an incredible Macro and fantastic Telephoto performer. Plus - it's the most fun camera I have ever used.
Posted Oct 2, 2012 9:19:44 AM
By varun
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
what about the Sony NEX C3? with the f3 out recently, C3 should be available at a discount. other than full HD video, what are the major differences? is it worth paying extra for the F3?
Posted Aug 28, 2012 11:27:28 AM
By Dick De Jong
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
We have the D-5 in for review. It's a great, stylish camera. I find it a bit pricey at almost $1000 for the body only. Ultimately, you need to decide if the premium is worth it.
Posted Aug 18, 2012 10:15:18 AM
By Peggy
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
Ready to purchase the Olympus OMD 5...any feedback?
Posted Aug 16, 2012 11:09:42 AM
By Chris
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
I was wondering the same thing! Been looking very hard at the Olympus OM-D E-M5 and would like to hear your opinions on it.
Posted Aug 14, 2012 4:42:30 PM
By Bill Steen
Post a Comment Alert Moderator
Thoughts about the Olympus OMD 5?